Crimson Longinus's latest activity

Yeah, agreed. But my point is that you cannot really get fully rid of adjudication thus the rules cannot ever be "complete" in manner...

Because then you would likely have to go back and rewrite all of your history to match the newly created reality. Do you, or the players...

But it still requires some adjudication. What objects qualify as improvised weapons? And if all improvised weapons do not have same...

I just don't want to be telling to the players that their characters cannot try to cut a rope with a frozen herring just because the...

Which makes "Purple Dragon Knight" a bad name. But that the subclass is a relatively generic knight-commander instead of some super...

But what this has to do with me or 5e spell rules?

I don't think that's necessarily true. If you accept that's going to happen at least in uncommon events, you can make sure to build...

I really don't think that's necessary, especially once you add some expected genre/structure constraints and zoom out the abstraction a...

So I am not quite sure we understand "incomplete" in the same way. I think it is a salient feature of RPGs that you can try to do...

At least you've finally admitted that players in a traditional RPG are contributing to the shared fiction instead of being railroaded.

I think that's more dogma than fact, but more importantly I think directionally wrong for design. Starting from an assumption that your...

I get your point, but I do have to say that I've never seen or heard of a Power Attack spreadsheet. Why would power attack need a...

That seem too easy. You surely not saying that the players author the entire world by asking the GM to run a game for them? In this...

Disagree with me on what? What you think my opinion on D&D spell rules is?

Yes, this happens. This on the other hand doesn't. To do this fully is impossible in any RPG, and not even desirable. However, one...