Recent content by Cruentus

  1. C

    Dungeons & Dragons Playtests Four New Mystic-Themed Subclasses

    WOTC said that things printed in their 5e hardback books were canon. But nothing before those was canon. And, of course, your own table is as canon as your group wants it to be. As it’s always been.
  2. C

    D&D 5E (2014) Real Emotions at the Gaming Table

    Early on in my playing days (Ad&d, maybe earlier) I had a fighter who fought Slicer Beetles. If they rolled well enough they could lop off a limb. Well, it did, severing my first level character's hand. After we killed it, I took my hand with me back to town, and asked around "Do you have a...
  3. C

    D&D General Adventurers a distasteful necessity

    He can be if he spent time in the village or town Militia. If he returned from a military campaign by the local lord, or if he helped defend his town from bandits. Also, in my worlds, I always make my NPC's exactly like PCs, using classes, armor, magic items, etc. If one has access to...
  4. C

    TSR The Shadow Elves of Mystara

    Likely Fiend Folio. And they weren't just moustaches, they were particularly spectacular 70's vintage 'staches.
  5. C

    Other D&D Variant Best D&D Clone for open table play with beginners?

    I don't know if it fits your categories, but I'd give Beyond the Wall and Other Adventures a look. Its OSR at its base, has a solid char gen using 'playbooks' for archetypes, which shape your character, and build in relationships to other characters and the starting village. It can be as...
  6. C

    D&D General How Did You Generate Your Most Recent Character's Stats?

    3d6 down the line. That's how I roll. I played in a B/X game recently where my highest ability score was a 12, we reached 5th level, I had a fun time and would like to continue with that character. We're playing Symbaroum next, and using their array (which you can then modify). I found it...
  7. C

    What's the best potato?

    1. Steak Fries 2. French Fries 3. Hash Browns (for breakfast) 4. Roasted in the chicken pan with other root vegetables (and the chicken drippings)
  8. C

    Netflix announces deal to buy WB and HBO

    I'll be priming the "cancel Netflix" muscles until I see what censorship has to occur, and what pockets lined (sorry, donations to 'funds' occur), to actually make the merger go through. I certainly wouldn't mind having fewer than 30 streaming services to go through to find what I'd like to...
  9. C

    Pineapple Express: Someone Is Wrong on the Internet?

    No idea what happened to them, we lost touch. But I did hear that Billie and Patti had a 10lb baby boy. Billy even wrote a letter to Patti’s parents to try to explain. That boy must be like 45 at this point.
  10. C

    D&D General Mike Mearls says control spells are ruining 5th Edition

    Where is that rule from? Its not in the MM1 or under the Red Dragon. I know we never played with any rule like that back when we played Ad&d in the early eighties.
  11. C

    Pineapple Express: Someone Is Wrong on the Internet?

    Nuh uh. Nuh uh. Nuh uh. Moves goalposts
  12. C

    Netheril's Fall - First Impressions

    Having done a ton of research to add some Netheril into an ongoing campaign I'm running, my take on Elves, and Netheril, lines up almost exactly like @Maxperson. Elves in my campaign have deep lore knowledge, pass that lore and learning down amongst themselves, and things that are 3,000 to...
  13. C

    D&D 5E (2024) The Dalelands & Myth Drannor : Are they inseparable ?

    I added "Myth Drannor" into my Moonshaes campaign. I shrouded it in rumor, and made it very clear how dangerous it was to enter. That didn't stop the players from beelining directly to it anyway. I used it primarily as a ruined city, full of atmosphere and wandering monsters, which could be...
  14. C

    OSR New edition of OSE in 2026 (updated with some links)

    I tried to extend the Fighter's weapon specialization and Combat Dominance (Surge mechanic) to "martial characters", with the effect that no one took the Fighter, ever. A Knight is better, Paladin and Ranger have more "stuff", etc. There is no actual reason to take a Fighter, particularly...
  15. C

    [Old school] I can't deal with inventory

    I've not seen any encumbrance systems that worry about your injury level. We use coin based encumbrance (using OSE) when we play on a VTT, as the VTT handles all the calculations for weight, your encumbrance, your move speed, and any changed therein in real time. When we play at the table, we...
Top