darjr's latest activity

well it’s about RPGs a subjective pastime almost all the way down. Sorry it’s frustrating. I’m kinda reveling in it. Not just some...

Here’s the OP actual question after some background. Your mileage may vary but that looks like an invitation to talk about the...

Just bumping this.

It’s also about PBTA and other games. I saw the original post about the technique and DH was just the recent illustration.

Thank you for the link.

Yeah, I really like this blog post by John Harper about "crossing the line", and the difference between asking a player to take...

One way I help make this less of a problem is to not make it a "Demand". When I ask a player to contribute, if they pause as though they...

Now I want to run an extreme Monty Haul campaign just to see what I’d have to do to run it without scheming to remove the haul. I...

A hard line on this seems to contradict “rulings not rules”. can’t like and laugh emoji at the same time!

To start, you don't usually do this to this level. "You walk outside. What is this planet called and what is this biome like?" is a...

I knew it! :) I would have added “for a particular style” but if wishes were fishes.

Oh, and to quote from the DH Book a bit, here's the GM guidance around this. You'll note it presents a range of possibility here, and...

Not all of them.

Sure I see that, but so is extreme optimization. Or an insistence to PVP. Or chaotic behavior. Or siding with the villains against the...

Those who like the Daggerheart approach are the ones talking about engagement and not immersion from my perspective on those words...