dave2008's latest activity

My apologies @EzekielRaiden , I see now that you let this thread. Sorry to summon you back. Feel free to ignore if you want (though I...

I think I was focusing more on the logic aspect and less on the plausibility aspect. People are not logical so you can't plausibly...

A 750-page thread built around arguing that GM-led sandboxing circa 1983 is some new or revelatory cutting edge rpg tech. I see where...

Sounds like we're back to: different people like different things.

Well, for my part and in fairly general terms: "Plausible" implies a reasonably easy-to-follow (or in the case of hidden information...

I mean people have been talking about how DMs have done this since the game started. So while it may not make sense to some, I think it...

Hussar why are you so hostile to this notion. Worst case scenario: Rob injects some fun along with plausibility. But it seems perfectly...

I have to be honest I did not find your question to be very clear. I am not sure how I can answer it to your satisfaction. The only...

Yep, that is what we do too. My only point is that there is not some grand internal logical other then what we (me and my group) think...

I would like events to proceed in a plausible fashion (subject to my and my players conception of what is plausible, of course) all the...

I'm jumping in late so I don't know if you are correct on this or not. I have noticed some people discussing plausibility. So, IMO, it...

At some point, if you still don't understand these things after a few thousand posts, you have to decide it's time to just accept that...

I don't know the meaning of that term (I don't play or design video games), care to explain? I didn't know the meaning of this term...

People do explain why. The problem is you have a specific answer in mind and anyone whose explanation isn't that answer is ignored at...

Everyone already knows that D&D has a ton of them. There's no double standard here.