dave2008's latest activity

I am not sure either. I like ability scores, but I do wish they were more fleshed out.

In the version of the Hobbit I read it described the large goblins as orcs. I don't know if that was the version before our after tLorR...

There is a fine line between what you suggest and wanting some of the ideas of Shadowdark with a bit of D&D polish. I like Shadowdark...

I fear cell phones have been overly destructive to society. It is not just them of course, but the ability to have the internet, and all...

OK, is it weird to now want to see a 6E that is simply a reprint of AD&D 2E that is entirely lore accurate in meticulous detail??

@Micah Sweet has answered this before: they don't like Hasbro and would prefer to not purchase their products. So they would prefer...

That is not what they are suggesting. They are say use the modifiers only (it is in the part you quoted) like PF2. So instead of a...

It does, however, magically become a much more popular game if it's called Dungeons and Dragons, which immediately expands the potential...

yeah, you basically recommend they make a 6e you are not being tempted by, interesting take ;)

I'm sorry. I though I was specifically told we weren't supposed to consider what the people who own the D&D brand would actually make...

You can have a resource game without tying the recharge to the nightly sleep narrative, though.

Also there WAS sending in LotR. Between palantirs and talking to moths, there was a lot of long range communication. Not to mention...

This I an agree with: This, not so much: To me, that is akin to saying: make taking meth integral to the game.

While I agree with your conceit about 1e, we applied the same philosophy to 4e and 5e: lots of "...winging things or making up your own...

I like a lot of this, but getting rid of the attack roll is a non starter for me. Not a big fan of Luck and Doom points either, but that...