dave2008's latest activity

My group ultimately rejected A5e because of the added complexity too. I like a lot of it design-wise so I still buy a lot of the books...

IME, they are not superior in play to the 5e24 MM. With the exception that the MM doesn't have anything equivalent to A5e elite, 5e14...

It does it at the cost of extra rules and more things to keep track of though. That was ultimately my player's feedback after our A5e...

Personally, I think people would pick every part of them to shreds. A5e and TotV (especially TotV) get a pass because they are NOT WotC.

What? Why wouldn't you just use a shortbow? Why should a sword act like a shortbow? How can a sword act like a shortbow? If you are...

Blaming a corporation for trying to create a popular product that their audience likes is futile too though… Realistically the option...

yes, but if level 3 is already beyond my ‘comfort level’ then that does not leave much of a level range for me to work with ;) If...

Which, IMO, is an even more difficult thing to nail down for everyone. One can always simply start their game at Level 3 or 5 or 11 if...

It's a little too late to introduce that for the primary characters but I'm not to worried since the group is already 15th level so...

Yup. Something on the popularity level of 4e (liked by some, disliked by others) would be my ideal. Again, imaginary wishes thread.

That is thing though. D&D would have to be significantly less popular, or less accommodating (looking at you 4e), for it to not persuade...

I understand that idea, but homebrew is ingrained into my conception of D&D. I am much more likely to homebrew D&D than I am to try a...

I dunno maybe you should have quoted that bit instead of an entirely other bit? But that's still word salad really, because D&D...

I thought the same thing happened if I blocked someone. I just want to make sure it is not on my end. I can't stop someone from...

yes, that was a response to the proposals by @GobHag not about 5e