Recent content by delericho

Either the sorcerer or a new class - it depends on how many classes the hypothetical 6e has. Alternately, rebuild all the classes with a simple chassis that you can then optionally add complexity to. Though that would be a fairly radical reworking of the game, I think.

But to engage with the premise of the thread in good faith, I'd look to make two big changes: - Get rid of ability scores completely - no 3-18 range, but not even the modifier. Roll most of what the ability scores do into the classes directly, but then expand the use of feats to provide...

I wouldn't. With the D&D movie flopping, the TV show(s) seemingly being in development hell, Stranger Things ending, and Critical Role seemingly losing steam, D&D is dropping out of the zeitgeist - possibly only briefly, but potentially for a very long time. Under those circumstances, the last...

I've generally taken the view that we're quorate if 3/4 of the group are present; if not, we cancel. Unfortunately, I've now twice had groups shrink to the point where even a single absence took us below the threshold, at which point it becomes better to fold the group than to struggle on. (For...

I was about to say exactly that. Though I'm not sure that's a bad thing. That said, Nottingham and its environs are a lot more vertical and a lot less forested than I'd expected.

In general, AI is a tool, much like any other, and can be used in good ways and bad ways (both in terms of quality and ethically). So I'm not automatically against it. That said, the overwhelming majority of actual uses of AI have fallen on the bad side of the equation in one way or another. So...

I don't really believe in a 'best'. My favourites are Eberron, Spelljammer, Dark Sun, and Ravenloft, probably in that order.

One last D&D reference: TPK. (But, no, not really. Campaigns mostly don't end like that.)

The point buy options aren't all balanced, and indeed intentionally so. However, the optimum assignment is not entirely obvious - it will generally depend on the character's class(es) and other factors. Point buy is better than the standard array - because most characters have a strong...

I was in a place called "The Newsroom" on Leith Street yesterday which was surprisingly pleasant - despite being the last weekend before Christmas it was surprisingly calm. The other place we usually end up is the Guildford Arms. (Sorry - I don't have much experience with pubs or restaurants in...

Swear vociferously. Then play the character. (I haven't been with a group that rolls stats in a long time. I don't think I'd play with a DM who tried to insist on it, and given the choice I would strongly tend to go for point buy/standard array. However, I have run games for players who prefer...

No gaming at all - no running games, no playing games, no prepping a campaign, no new products bought (but see below), no books read. I've posted maybe a dozen times here, but for the most part I'm out, for a while at least (no idea how long "a while" is). While I didn't buy any new products, I...

Isn't the correct answer to that "both"? :)

It's the "adding stuff" that I like to see - I'm not bothered if it's then later ignored or contradicted by primary sources. If nothing else, shows like Star Trek and Doctor Who reality ignore, change, and discard bits of their own established continuity, so it's too much to ask that they honour...

A good licensed game will construct the mechanics to suit the setting (rather than just shoe-horning the setting into an existing set of mechanics). I generally found that running Star Wars d6 or Firefly felt like those respective universes, in a way that other games tended not to. (In...