ECMO3's latest activity

So you weaken fighters and Monks in tier 2 to be more in line with Clerics and Druids and now all 4 of them are weaker than Wizards and...

It is worth more than a 5th level slot at 9th level and at 17th level, when you can use it 3 times with a +17 on the save, it is...

That is not easy, especially if you look across all 20 levels. I am going to use specific classes here, because Martial is ambiguous...

For most PCs from the Fighter, Monk and Rogue classes I think casting spells is something they do. So I don't believe this is true in...

I can't comment much on top tier play with D&D2024, having only played through a single level 20 one-shot and watched a few actual play...

That may be the distinction when you are white rooming it and talking about classes, but when you are talking about actual PCs I think...

Being "not a bad business tactic" (and that is debatable) is not the same as being a "successful business tactic"

Creamcloud said the first two were not martials. This illustrates the problem, we can't even agree on what we are talking about here as...

A few of the higher level martial features are equal or better than a 5th level spell (Indomitable for one off the top of my head). I...

All things which were part of 2E. You are saying 2E was a failure because of how they rolled out the new edition, not because they...

Ok, that still does not explain the logic regarding why releasing 2E was a "successful business tactic" There is absolutely no evidence...

Personally, I think Martial and Caster are talking about two different things, two different traits and they are not exclusionary. IMO...

Ok. Then we accepted that spells are ok on a martial (i.e. High Elf Champion), so logically spells are a viable way to balance them at...

i think we need some definitions. So a Ranger, paladin or High elf champion are not martials on this discussion? Reguarding high-level...

Giving martials spells does not kill martials, they are still martials with spells (like Rqangers and Paladins already are). Also I am...