ECMO3's latest activity

I don't think this is true. Plenty of people love fighters, and other martials. I don't think very many people like non-casters...

No I mean spell slots and spells prepared. They are still martials, Rangers and Paladins all cast spells, would you say they are not...

First off this is not the easiest way. By far the easiest way to close the gap at levels where casters are better is to leave the...

2E sales were not bad at all, but the release of 2E was a disaster financially for TSR. We are nto talking about theory here, we are...

I would say you are wrong. I would say it was a terrible decision. But generating sales is not everything in terms of being a good...

I don't think so, maybe, but it is hardly a harbringer of success. Whether or not it would have happened anyway, we can confidently say...

Like I said it depends on your metric. If you are going to ask if adoption has been "enthusiastic", you need some metric by which to...

It was only really a successful business tactic from 4E to 5E. Looking historically: 1E to 2E --> Not successful and drove TSR into...

So you're not arguing for what would be better for WotC D&D 5e fans... or even fans of '24 Revised...You're arguing for...Because it's...

And I wouldn’t rule out the social pressure of expectations they would do something to recognize the 50th anniversary.

It depends on the metric. The new 2024 rulebooks are vastly outselling the previous expansion books published in the last few years, so...

But that's not the product fans want... I don't think a fan wants those changes totally divorced from the D&D 5th editiion rules. They...

FWIW I don't.

Eh, the only people I've seen clamoring for a total break from 5e and a totally different edition to be produced... aren't fans of D&D 5e.

Well since you don't actually play D&D and haven't since before the revised corebooks came out and you also seem to dislike WotC as a...