Emerikol's latest activity

That may be true. They are acceptably happy with it. I've never played in a single campaign that I was 100% happy with but I also...

This contention though is a big irritant to me. It is dismissive that I do not choose my games for reasons. When I say I like a game...

Are you saying you like railroading?

I think a retroclone will "fix" the 1e stuff I don't like. 2e THAC0 is not great either. I prefer the d20 system but the 1e rules...

It's a very solid game. I still want a skill system but I could play C&C any time. I own a lot of it.

This would be the point. If the idea has enough players, and I have turned away players just to keep the group size manageable, then it...

Cracking the code of a game that will fit Retreater's entire group requires a Rosetta Stone I do not have. :)

Other than thieves, I didn't mind the balance. I preferred those other things in fact I prefer the 1e versions of them which is why I'm...

This is just your strawman scaremongering you always resort to in these discussions. Of course the GM needs to sell their premise to the...

This is key. Session 0 is absolutely a must have and the DM needs to be detailed in what he is allowing and not allowing as well as what...

Tieflings are probably the race I like the least.

I think you may be presenting the tone of DM #1 as being more harsh than necessary. I think the best way to do a "curated" campaign is...

I am not sure whether that is exactly what simulationism means to many here but for me the player only interacting with the world...

One thing about retroclones. They tend to clean up and systematize the older edition. That means most of the things bad about 1e are...

I think 3e did a lot of things right but not everything. If I had to play exactly by the rules, I'd play 3e if I had to play a D&D...