Emerikol's latest activity

It may just be that verisimilitude is essential to the players enjoying the campaign. I seek those sorts of players. It does vary by...

Well, several factors. The dice indicates something special happens. The player is going to be looking at the DM to tell him what that...

No good deed goes unpunished EzekielRaiden. If someone disagrees with you, the interpretation of motives is always the most evil possible.

Thanks for the help. So when we talk about fail forward, I always think of the Star Wars game with that extra die that indicates...

I would be extremely surprised if Lanefan has a positive reaction to knowing this, as IIRC he does not play 5e and has a skeptical view...

I was asking what the debate, that was ongoing here, was about. I came in late so I was just trying to be sure I knew what exactly are...

Well that is the gist of it. Does the cook exist prior to seemingly popping into existence or is the cook just made up on the fly? So...

If the DM's campaign world has a cook in that home then yes, otherwise no.

What does surrender even mean here? People see these things as different. That is an undeniable fact. Read the thread. You can argue...

Because they exist in the DMs world. The DM has just decide to let randomness determine WHERE they are at vs if they exist at all...

We could debate semantics but lets not. I'd just say there is a difference. The DM has established the monsters that could be roaming in...

I think I started playing with crits in 1e and used them through 4e. I haven't played 5e to date. I dislike the swingyness of the d20...

Folks just so you know, bad logic bugs me even when my "team" uses it. I will point it out even if I agree with the overall position of...

That is an argument against the mechanism and not the plausibility. Remember my original quote said I probably agree overall with the...

I kept hearing about the game but didn't know the details. Now I do. It's not my type of game but I'm sure it will make some here...