Enrahim's latest activity

Sure. It would also be a terrible game, with basically no agency. I mean, I don't really care, personally. Simplicity is widely...

I was not responding to your response about my point about targets being more visible. I was responding to your claim that Which I have...

I think you must have missed the context. This is the example we are discussing (some steps up the reply chain) For this example...

I adressed this exact proposal in the post you replied to. Minor shadowdark quickstart spoiler

Decign and principles are hard. If this principle as formulated here the game "Flip a coin whenever you are unsure" would be more...

I believe it was @Maxperson that introduced this use of challenge. When I replied to his concerns, I thought it made sense to adapt the...

Well it might be true I did not "clearly define it". However as you point out I provide an attempt of describing how it "feels". Just...

agreed. I would say for the game as a whole taking any temporary stance won't effect the game much.....unless you take an extreme...

The last part here indicate we are not disagreeing at all with regard to the enumeration part? You open for novel interactions, which...

This is the problem with these proposals: It requires a sort of negotiation ahead of the roll. To take an extremely simple example: What...

The challenging part is the unnoticed part ;) If anything I would say the dilemma here is if it is the stealth skill or the thief tools...

Fair enough. I use "random stocking" techniques in my games.

This would require enumerating actions? In that case that is completely counter to the TTRPG medium. We are then quickly into boardgame...

In the lock picking, fail forward case: success means you get in, no cook. Fail means you get in, cook. What you're describing changes...

I looked up the exact rule in question. In ShadowDark if your light go out, the environement become deadly meaning you roll random...