Enrahim's latest activity

your assertions that they are 'equally quantum' are untrue when for one roll the chances of the location of the cook has modifiers...

Things can get weird because a lot of Narrativist best practices aren't actually best practices and what gets ported between games is...

For him. You can't apply that to any of the rest of us who haven't said we do it like that. I don't.

I gave a quite extensive answer to this previously, but that is a bit dense, and relly on terminology I have since rejected. I'll link...

Honestly… I think maybe the core bit of disagreement is that I don’t think the world should be independent.

Yes, I am pretty sure that is the case. The independence of the world is in conflict with the wish to have a good story strongly focused...

Yes, the DM can do a lot of things...this specific type of thing does not result in gameplay that I, as a player or GM, find satisfying...

Did you see this? This go into the core why this particular technique stabs into the heart of the notion of independence i a very real...

Nice clarification. I use the "illusion" not as a negative term. Rather I have previously found it usefull to prevent the predictable...

Yes, in 5ed a GM can introduce a flying tarasque throwing icream around while singing born to be wild. That doesn't mean that it is good...

Yay! We are getting somewhere! You see the distinction. And of course it is pointless to make for you as you are not interested in...

It might help them go undetected by potential observers, but it shouldn't affect the presence of potential observers.. Edit: did you...

it's not inconsistent, the wandering monster is not being determined by the same roll that the players are using for a check, it is...

I am replying this far back, as your back and forth with @Maxperson is a dead end. You are right about that the roll determines the...

TLDR: BW Revised (edit - not to be confused with gold revised) and Gold turn out to be completely different games in scope of this...