Enrahim's latest activity

Yeah, this is one point of disconnect. If the players in your game are not trying to win, if the social contract underlying it says that...

As I just stated above, the crumbling rock is there on success or failure. If it's a particularly high DC I may narrate the crumbling...

The player decided what the runes said, which is fine in a collaborative style game. I just don't happen to want to play that style of...

To your first question: Was it important for informing a decission? In that case no. Is it important enough for someone to want to...

Was the codeword "Mellon" by chance?

The existence of a problematic aspect of the wall was established when the need for a roll and the DC was determined. At this point...

Indeed, what would be surprising is if they weren’t there. Unless, of course, the players decided to do something sensible and break in...

Oh! This might be the keyword. Try to replace all occurrences of "action" with "attempt" in what I have said in the 5 or so last posts...

Ok. I accept that :) I am reading that passage quite differently. I agree that if it had indeed claimed that it would be ridiculous...

If a player declare their character climb a cliff, and resolution indicate they succeed on this task, then indeed the character will...

Yes, the player described an action. But they also expressed a hope. In this game this expression of hope turned out to be more potent...

The player affected the content of the fiction via different means than describing an action made by their character and having the...

The player hoping it was something dictated that it was the thing they hoped for because they succeeded. They shaped the world to what...

It was sort of true for 4ed, but it was not accepted as it only applied to the out of combat segment. In the in combat segment the rules...

Of course. Rolling the ability check in BW is of course not petioning the creator! Describing it as such would be just silly! The act...