Enrahim's latest activity

I think the answer here is very simple. Free Kriegspeil tried to improve simulation by getting rid off all the mechanics. I think it is...

The troubleling thing with the conversation is that while 1 and 2 might be right, trying to nail down anything more spesific is so...

Nope. They look at what seem to go on in trad game, think they can codify it to produce the same behavior, and miss that the...

So you see how I consider the entire notion of "simulationistic game" silly? Even the conversation about how some rules might be better...

You are now trying to impose a single definition of "sim" onto a conversation that has shown that there are a lot of understandings of...

Because it clearly was an "errata". They didnt have the distribution technology to effectively distribute otherwise at that point in...

Well, there are a billion-and-one adventures for DW. They should pretty much all go into a dumpster with some gasoline. The people...

Well, the absence of pre written adventures for PbtA games might just be that the entire structure and philosophy behind basically makes...

Yes and in my breakdown of differences between how I run D&D compared to DW, I didn't claim to not use any of the moves. I singled out a...

Well have I ever run a "combat" (technical term) without using the rules for "combat" (technical term)? No because the technical term is...

Yes, that is the DW prescribed approach :) I do see it could provide an effect. I just know that is definitely not what I am currently...

Agreed, but pemerton's right in that WotC-era D&D combat resolution with hard-coded turns does overly break it down into stop-motion...

Modern D&D might not be all that sim-friendly but it doesn't take much to push TSR-era D&D a reasonable distance toward sim; there's a...

Thank you for being so kind to keep this up! I feel like there is some progression here, and I enjoy this more than it might seem. I...

So when the players decide they want to attack, you look at the situation and decide that they don't have to enter combat?