Enrahim's latest activity

What seperates negotiating over fiction from the negotiations of diplomacy or Catan? Especially Diplomacy provide me plenty of...

Have you instructed them to stay quiet if they find anything objectionable? If I am sufficiently present of mind in session I would...

Wait a second - are you staying full information is needed for a TTRPG to be gamist?

I think you might be confusing "to obey" and "obedience" ref: "Willing to obey" indicate obedience can be found even in a situation...

I thought the argument against "Be fan of the PCs" etc wasn't an argument against pithy phrasing itself, but rather a complaint that...

Because the game does provide "any" information. It's quite clear how the stat, skill, and other modifiers affect your roll to show you...

This seems insufficient. You could as easily port that understanding to any board game that involves dice in resolution; the point is...

Did you not read any of my posts in which I said that this is not a game about solving puzzles or overcoming GM-authored challenges so...

The paramount question is ‘how are they wanting to overcome said obstacle’. In the runes example the player must decide what he wants to...

Turns out, different participants have different roles.

l I’m confused here. The runes don’t have dynamic features?

I think that's probably the wrong axis for that question. The relevant point is the nature of the action; in case B the relative impact...

Are we going to make any real attempt to get at why some mechanics cause a backlash and others don't? It looked like for a moment we...

Then we're missing steps. Perhaps whatever the "simulation" (probably the wrong term, but we're stuck here) thing is we're taking about...

I think the core fault line is whether one wants to try to correlate the player decision space with the character decision space or not...