Enrahim's latest activity

But the method of establishment is what is under scrutiny here! In the cleric example the existence was handwaved. I thought the point...

Oh, I must have missed that!? I have not recognised that at all! I tought they repeatedly stated the character cannot determine the...

Never mind. Thought I saw a a way do deescalate, but upon closer inspection it didn't read the way I intended.

Not really. I have seen and experienced some very closed form games that has been labeled RPG (reasonably in my eyes). Also systems that...

I'm more a modern roguelike guy, but sure. I just think tabletop environments with my friends and a dedicated person for content...

Then it seem like the design space you are looking at has been quite heavily explored in computer games. Elite, Minecraft, terrarria, no...

I would say exactly the same for sim play with highly dynamic content :)

I just realised: If you take Talisman, and remove the inner circle+gate. Would that pass your test for being an RPG? Play time is...

So I am not quite sure we understand "incomplete" in the same way. I think it is a salient feature of RPGs that you can try to do...

Edit: I think I got the wrong context. Never mind.

I’ve never seen a game handle improvised weapons and objects particularly well. Do you have some specific rules in mind you feel are...

That seem too easy. You surely not saying that the players author the entire world by asking the GM to run a game for them? In this...

Well, TTRPGs have a long tradition of having key play being structured. Early D&D could be played as a pure mechanical dungeon crawler...

I don't think we disagree then. However I would point out that "game" has a lot of overloaded meanings. When I talk about game in this...

I think I see where you are coming from. However I struggle to see how to avoid negotiation in TTRPG in a good way. I think this might...