ersatzphil's latest activity

So, like I said. The two things don’t work together without changing one or both to the point of no longer being itself.

Can you actually address my point rather than the point you made up in your head? I'm not complaining about there being a "cosmic...

Bloodborne has shown beyond a shadow of a doubt that gothic horror and cosmic horror can work together to incredible effect. But the...

But, like, tell me how the Great Race makes sense in the game…?

The art is pretty unmistakable. And both Cthulhu and the Great Race have D&D history as both where in the original Deities & Demigods...

Right, but I don’t want the Cthulhu Mythos to cross over with Ravenloft. I think both are better as their own things. We’ve established...

The Beadle & Grimm Curse of Strahd box came with a deck that was 3.25" x 5.25".

I can see it.

I mean - I would argue that you can do horror in D&D, just not every kind of horror. D&D is (usually) a world where the Divine exists as...

The same could be said of Nancy Drew, that doesn’t mean she would be a good choice to include in the book.

I agree with you that that could very well be the rationale behind it, but "Cthulhu has to be in Ravenloft because Cthulhu is horror and...

Yeah, this definitely works better in Call of Cthulhu, Trail of Cthulhu, Alien or Mothership, in my opinion, but "can D&D do horror" is...

I'm going with Appendix N having a long shadow, and Ravenloft being the catch-all "dark" kitchensink.