EzekielRaiden's latest activity

When did I say none? When did I say that? Please argue against the posts I'm actually making, rather than whatever you have mistaken...

It is neither. Unless you think God is your Dungeon Master. Which, well. I certainly think some folks act like they think God is their...

The GM provides the rails. The agency is in where you look while you're riding them.

Ah, and see how you used the negative example, but not the positive one? Clearly I'm the one with a nasty evil agenda, not just using...

If you already know the contents of every hex well before players enter it, how is the world not nailed down? It's your theme park...

Nope! There are ways to have structured fiction generation with constraints. That's literally why Hussar brought up Ironsworn. In that...

.... You are making this point to me when I literally gave a spectrum of options about this as one of my first posts in the thread, and...

Invisible rails. I know you already know of this "technique." We had a thread about it a while back and I'm 99% sure you posted in it...

But this too involves DM permission, no? This is where that aforementioned "strict" definition of "sandbox" comes into play. Sure...

If a prisoner never makes an effort to leave the prison before their sentence is finished, are they still imprisoned? Or are they free...

Ironsworn would be one such RPG (from the same general space as PbtA/FitD games). That choice would be "leave the sandbox." Your...

This seems a total non sequitur to me. It isn't the players asking to suddenly jump from Forgotten Realms to Spelljammer (or anything...

Not sure why you think I’d disagree. But the argument is that because the dm can say yes to player suggestions that suddenly makes it...

I'd extend the analogy further: Imagine snakes-and-ladders, but instead of dice, you have piles of envelopes marked with "cautious"...

This does not strike me as sufficient for agency. Imagine a game of snakes-and-ladders, played not by rolling dice but by drawing...