EzekielRaiden's latest activity

I mean, I guess? But doesn't that rather poke a hole in your claim that "game" is something that actually integrates all the stuff? You...

But again that makes point 7 completely irrelevant. If everyone agrees that making the "veracity and truth" of the world inviolate is...

But the huge, huge, huge, huge, huge, huge, huge, huge difference: In this, no party is keeping a massive store of knowledge that...

Perhaps. Just from that very first principle, however, I find something to at least raise my eyebrows at. "If, at any point, any aspect...

Well, I don't! I think all of those should be classes, and a few more besides. (I'm of the opinion that 5e is missing between five and...

Not in anything more than very remotely like D&D. I might be able to enjoy an evening of Paranoia, where you legitimately have multiple...

I pretty thoroughly disagree, but part of that is because, as I've said previously, I don't really feel you have given a fair shake to...

I think this perfectly encapsulates exactly why I have not merely zero but extreme negative interest in this sort of thing. That, quite...

Perhaps I am. I don't think the things you bring up are actually a counterexample to what I've said. I see that as "I really love these...

I don't see how. Three points were made. 1. We cannot design "a game"--in the way @clearstream defined such, noting that I deeply...

No. But this is such a disingenuous argument I cannot reasonably respond to it. Like I genuinely do not understand how anyone seriously...

I mean, there might be exceptions? But they're going to be VASTLY outnumbered by things that follow the pattern. Rules design is a...

Then people need to stop calling 5e a game, because it isn't a game by this standard. It's a game "system". Also the word "campaign" is...

When I say "almost all of the time", I mean so often that many people will never encounter an exception. Hence why, even in my original...

Okay but like...what do we DO with that? Because now that means discussing 5e is genuinely impossible. There is no such thing as "5e"...