Faolyn's latest activity

It has nothing to do with how eloquently you talk in my games. You could literally say "I remind the king of the time we saved his...

Well. That page just sucks all the fun out of roleplaying. In a D&D game (and just about every other RPG out there), you don't use...

They have to speak. Does the GM decide if they are "speaking robotically" or if it's not adequately addressing the situation? But...

I believe the readers of the thread now have the information to arrive at their own conclusions on the accuracy of @AlViking statement...

Poh-tae-toe poh-tah-toe. In D&D the player decides what their character is emotionally and mentally capable of. Totally different...

A player can choose to have their character hesitate. The player can even choose to roll a die to see if they hesitate. But it's the...

If you don't have anything of value to add, why bother responding? I asked a simple question, one I have asked many times with the same...

Depends heavily on the GM, player, and circumstances. At my table, it's a bit more common for the player to come up with a reason than...

Last time that happened, we played a Lasers & Feelings hack (Magical Pets).

To me, a fairly clear example of a player being given meta-agency would be this conversation: Player: "I look down the alley. What do...

Note that pemerton also said a game in which the players had one choice in where to go, and if they didn't go in that direction the game...

No, you hadn't. Not even one time.

Right. Hawkeyfan has spoken. Heceforth no one should waste their time with that and, if they chose to do so, they must be playing wrong...

In that particular case, the character had the beliefs about getting revenge and instincts about always being right. That instinct alone...

Pemerton, you’ve repeatedly accused me of mischaracterizing your views. I disagree. What I’ve done is analyze your arguments using a...