Fenris-77's latest activity

  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    You hush.
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    Yeah, but it's not. Not for, say a wizard, or even a thief. Combat is a significant fail state for some classes in many games. We're...
  • Fenris-77
    An interesting outlier in this conversation is a game called Vagabonds of Dyfed. It uses a PbtA base, adapted for S&S play (not...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    Beyond that there are all kinds of possible combat actions one might attempt, depending on system. Again, it's not trivial.
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    Dying is never trivial.
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    Um, the consequence is getting ganked in the liver instead of gloriously killing yet another rabid kobold. Opportunity cost perhaps, I...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    An easier way to do that same bit is to use a hard gate. Assuming the party doesn't have passwall or anything, a magically locked door...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 reacted to bsss's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    With only a 10% chance to fail, thinking in game terms, that means he fails on a 1 or a 2 on a d20, so his bonus is amazing and/or the...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 reacted to Bill Zebub's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    You can't be faulted for not reading the entire thread, so I'll offer a couple of clarifications... There isn't, or shouldn't be. But...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    Not really, or at least that's not what I was talking about. There are lots of published adventures that gate all sorts of important...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    Locked doors are just a soft gate, and in this example are doing that job. I'd agree that it's not super interesting, but that's true of...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 replied to the thread Why I Hate Skills.
    I loathe gotcha traps, so yeah, this. If they radiate powerful magic or some shizz and the players still decides to read them then...
  • Fenris-77
    I like a lot of different character advancement schemes. For fantasy and some flavours of Sci-fi the idea of levels and that big...
  • Fenris-77
    Fenris-77 reacted to Bill Zebub's post in the thread Why I Hate Skills with Like Like.
    When running other people's adventures, which I like to do, this results in a lot of the content (except combat) essentially being...
  • Fenris-77
    I like Classes Rolling Stats Classes (and Ancestry/Species) give you a framework, while rolling stats works to prevent things from...
Top