The die pool doesn't change, no. Position is set by how advantageous the situation is for the PC and each level, Controlled/Risky/Desperate has increasingly bad consequences for a failed roll, but without changing the chances of success. Effect, Great/Standard/Limited is set by assessing a range...
Because it's a tough thing to attempt in the situation. It's not double jeopardy though, just a function of how Blades has both position and effect as adjudication tools. It's not like a D20 game where chances to hit are the only slider with damage as a constant. The flip side is that with...
Yup, that's a great way to not have fun playing Blades IMO. But if it works for someone else, great. It's no example of how the game is supposed to work though, that's for sure. 🤷♂️
I've never had any issues with the BitD skills. If a player is edge-casing they can but it'll lower position and or effect.
I'd agree with @hawkeyefan - there aren't five combat skills. There is one core combat skill (skirmish) and some others that can situationally be used in combat when that...
An example from something I did for publication. This is the set-up for an adventure of mine called Unseen Alchemeticals. The important part here isn't write-up to the left, but the faces in the crowd sidebar. The GM is probably going to need NPCs, so I made sure there were at least some seeds...
I design and publish my own stuff, so to some extent the answer here comes from that experience as well as prep I do for my own personal games.
I think, in short, that the answer is gameable material. Any prep I do that isn't immediately useful at the table is probably a waste of my time. A...
I'm not actually contesting the idea that good prep by an experienced GM leads to internally consistent setting deployment. I was only pointing out that there is a lot more going on than just do prep, profit. Some GMs are wizards with their prep, while other end up mangling sessions as they try...
I think that what counts as generative depends to some extent on resolution. So the introduction of the constable is certainly generative in the first example, but I'd probably call the second generative as well because the constable isn't part of established situation involving the purchase of...