FrogReaver's latest activity

I think we all care about something that could be called agency, but I still think I get your point. Like there is fundamental...

I actually don't think me, you or Micah care about agency at all. As it's conceived of by many of the Narratavists in this thread. I'm...

I think agency isn't about starting power. A player who is playing a god, and one who is playing a peasant, both have radically...

I'm not getting into the definitional argument here again, but I do want to point out, many of us wouldn't consider this a narrative or...

I am going to leave the prior points in this alone, not to avoid engagement but because I just think we are risking going down an...

At low levels the biggest concern is the temp hp. Unless the dm drastically changes encounters then almost nothing will even threaten...

Again, I think we just disagree, which is fine. Or perhaps we agree, but you are expanding that point of agreement into territory that...

I would push back on the second point. When we talk about player agency, I think we are really talking about the agency of their...

This is part of the key. A lot of people see agency more as a character's ability to make choices and do things within the setting...

Then I’ll ask in a different way. What makes those things greater forms of agency?

I don't think it is intentional but I do still think this in fact a straw man. I will try to address these point s though: I found some...

Insurance only does something in the event that the thing insured against occurs. it really isn’t. . Alternatively don’t use fireball...

Whist fire resistance and immunity are not uncommon, fire vulnerability and fire damage needed to stop regeneration are also not...

To me that line of reasoning establishes the player has agency. What you still haven’t done other than simply declare it to be so, is...

Unlike fireball, bless can do nothing. If no one misses by 1d4 then bless does nothing.