FrogReaver's latest activity

Okay. Don't do this. Just tell us what you are getting at. I don't have any interest in this kind of exchange

I think this is at the heart of a lot of the problems we have communicating in these threads. Which is some of us use much different...

It seems to me like less of a false premise and more of a definitional disagreement.

So I of course have not been present in your games, but by your description of them I do not believe this to be true. And I think games...

The language of calling it objective and real is not meant as an assault on other approaches. The point of taking this approach is you...

I don't know why this is such a controversial point. Again no one is saying it is genuinely real, or that it is like real world police...

Indeed. Not quite accurate. Regardless, my point about what is and isn't a real mystery stands. Now if you feel, (and I think you do)...

I never disputed your point. Also people keep saying I am limited to a view based only on trad play, and while I don't some of the...

That you have rules and procedures for who invents what doesn't mean you're not collaboratively inventing a mystery story rather than...

So agency comes from player being able to choose what they want their characters to say and attempt to do. The existence of an answer...

I'd understand calling that a "mystery" in the colloquial sense of it being unknown, but as both a mathematician and avid reader, I...

but th shoal of play can vary. We know nothing else about this campaign except a mystery adventure being run in this way us being...

Keep in mind where this part of the conversation came from. I was drawing a distinction between a mystery where you are really solving...

Many spells say "target you can see". But not all. Eldritch Blast doesn't. Also, if both parties are blind, then you get both...

Like with Sorcerer dice. You can just fiat, well not by the rules but you catch my drift. The dice aren't doing any mediation between...