FrogReaver's latest activity

I didn't say prep wasn't important. In fact I said planning out the details of the central mystery was essential for creating the...

Saying that the book could be organized better is putting things somewhat lightly... The amount of times an answer to something is in a...

Huh? First of all, this discussion is centered on mysteries in narrative games that don't have these details made up yet. That's why...

This is the no-myth interpretation but AW isn't a no-myth game. Dungeon World is really shaky, I don't think Adam and Sage knew what AW...

If GM prep is something that can remain objective around the mystery, I don't see the issue. This point wasn't about knocking AW or any...

In a setting for a game They aren’t at all. I would suggest your refusal to even concede there is such a thing as the players solving...

Also @pemerton I must emphasize once again this is a massive tangent over a throw away remark I made about 'real mysteries'. My overall...

Because it is about modeling causation in an imaginary space

We just have a basic disagreement on how to describe these things. I doubt either of us are going to convert the other to our way of...

Yes. But it is still people saying things, the system doesn't produce some independent truth apart the participants. And yes, there is...

It mostly helps inform their approach to play, not help them solve the mystery. Like if players know that there are no pre-established...

My Blades in the Dark experience encountered that. It wasn’t clear how to handle score like activities of limited scope occurring in...

What are flags? And yeah it is interesting to hear about the history. Some people have applauded story now games for generally being...

I disagree. The very knowledge that you have prepared a solution is information the players have that they can use to inform their play.

Yea. I don’t see it that way. But it’s just definitional semantics at this point.