FrogReaver's latest activity

Link the post and I will let you know what I think (provided it isn't like a page long). I do think when the material enters the game...

Because some of us feel the game isn't worth playing unless both are present, and the two things inform each other constantly...

Well, I think the problem we'd run into next is what is meant by "gameplay." My first point in this whole thread was saying the...

Goblin is one I’ve not seen mentioned much. I’ve seen quite a few of them. *Fun anecdote: Wizard goblins also make great barbarian...

Mainly the process used for learning that information.

Feels like we're about to do the immersion discussion. Let's please not do immersion. It's clear to me that nothing is to be gained in...

Your comparison to acting I think is very apt. If a person is portraying Sherlock Holmes, is that actor solving mysteries? Or are they...

The "realness" that has been referred to does not mean the sort of authenticity you allude to here. Why do you keep making this...

yes and because it is new many of us are much more wary of its conclusions. Especially since it is coming from within the hobby by...

Yeah, that was more or less why I saw it that way. There is a paper-thin layer of fiction pasted over the "solve a logic puzzle where...

It is jointly imagined. I don't think anyone disagrees with that. However, I reject that all possible jointly-imagined things are...

Also something that keeps coming up is that we are saying style X is uniquely objective. I don't know where this is coming from, but...

So, I've been checking in and out, because this whole thing is wild, but it seems to me that this has been rather too focused on the...

Because it is a game. Games are not like cars or computers. There are trends. And you can build on ideas over time. But you can do that...

See my previous post, where I lay out my issue with this process. It is creating fiction, but by the nature of that fiction it is far...