FrogReaver's latest activity

@AbdulAlhazred Would it be correct to characterize the type of game you bring up as quite distinct from blades in the dark? im kind...

Tying this thought back to the goals part of the discussion. Your scenario above and the generalization of it neither seem to entail a...

Would you say that in my play example given above, the player is just making it up?

Slow is okay if enemies have some distance to cover to get to the party and the party is not composed of some players that will charge...

But DnD doesn't work en-masse, unless that is how turn order rolls out for you. The also have frontguard, rearguard, etc... but more...

I like 3rd level combat magic to be something not terribly common. It's what makes sense in the world to me. Sure, some opponents are...

Yes, I ma quite familiar with that paragraph. It quite clearly illustrates the vagueness of myth in Blades compared to more trad...

Yeah but is the goal of the player the same as the character? To tie this into what @FrogReaver said. So I'm playing Apocalypse World...

I think I misinterpreted @thefutilist there, that question at the end of the post I was responding to seemed targeted at the narrativist...

Maybe I'm incorrect but to me the notion of play to find out seems to entail a more passive stance on the players part. I think that's...

Here is a section from the GM Best Practices chapter of Blades in the Dark. @Crimson Longinus I think you may find this section...

I think part of the reason this keeps getting brought up is that there are many past examples of players of trad rpgs using the term...

Survival, success of character goals etc. I get what you're saying, and I too think narrativism probably works better if you are not...

Right, his last post after mine was the first time in this tangent that different fighting styles were even introduced. What I did do...

I am having so much trouble following you guys conversation on this point. To me it sounds like @FrogReaver is talking about one player...