FrogReaver's latest activity

I haven't followed a lot of the subsequent torchbearer conversation but I am very unclear on how many of the specific rules work overall...

@Crimson Longinus @Bedrockgames @robertsconley @Faolyn You all have seen what’s been said about Torchbearer 2e in this thread and I...

Sorry, I was talking about TB2e. Can you elaborate?

This is the crux....ultimately the Hide rules in 2024 completely failed at their job. There is incredible confusion in the player base...

I mean, the best case scenario would be that the rules just be phrased in a way that doesn’t require such fuzzy interpretation. But...

That’s an interesting take. I dint think he said nor implied any level or type of argument. But I do see a value in talking about rules...

Exactly. Hearing the different angles in a forum also gives me a broader view of the issue. It's also very useful as a designer to see...

Depends how argumentative your players are. I think with my group I can get away with saying, I've discussed this with others online and...

But it could be to one’s benefit to have already heard the likely arguments.

Someone asked me why I cared, and I can say that when you organise public play every week in a store, you really don't want core rules...

I like arguing about rules on forums so that I don't have to argue about them at the table.

Halfing is in a fog cloud and had used the Hide action while there due to the Heavy Obscurement qualifying them for the Hide action...

I think this is a result of some core design decision to not invent a new "Hidden" condition, and someone really confident they could...

On the camp roll from TB and wandering monster checks in D&D. In a D&D wandering monster check the roll determines 1 thing, which if...

A few things in response to @pemerton's latest post, especially since he is trying to shift the framing of the discussion. My response...