FrogReaver's latest activity

but in most rpgs the opponents skill level and the referee and the screams of the crowd are determined by the GM. Hell the whole thjng...

Perhaps. Maybe. I'm not sure actually... Like yeah, it makes certain logical sense to view it like you say, but given that substance of...

"The rules were made for man, not man for the rules." Gygax 2:27 Good question. You could always just flip a coin giving every action...

It sounds like you want to play Descent or Hero Quest rather than an RPG. That's perfectly fine, but accepting your definition of...

D&D play style dominates, it isn't about wanting it is about only knowing that style. I have a disabled friend that likes RPG's, pushed...

Yeah, as I've said before when people start getting soggy about "semantic arguments", semantics matters; until you have an agreement...

I don't think you can skip the rhetorical step where you persuade people you're right. You either have to do that, and convince everyone...

The moment of judgement gets silly when it talks about who should have the authority. In most cases whoever has situational authority...

It's an interesting example as it relates to this thread because it's the exact type of move where I'd expect different groups to have...

Different abilities will be more or less useful in different settings. There’s nothing new here. In the typical d&d setting (based on...

No. I’m arguing that it depends on what ‘law enforcement’ is capable of in the preestablished setting (or others searching n for the...

Someone has to come up with jargon, and a criticall mass of other people have to agree to use it.

But maybe account for human nature? Like if you open a thread with "Styles X Y and Z think they have agency, but they are just fooling...

I am not Micah so I can;t speak for them. I can only speak for my own position. I think a lot of people would agree that an AP is...

@pemerton I am not interested in being antagonistic. I have a clear preference, but I really don't feel one style of play is...