FrogReaver's latest activity

As far as I could tell your statement didn’t include any comparison class.

Yes. The fact that D&D is so commonly used for a simulationist agenda (or play with no particular CA agenda that has simulationist...

Did I say it was not? It's simulating the attempt to open a lock. Nothing more, nothing less. It's obvious there's nothing I can...

Yes, I was noticing this. I hence updated my post slightly, but you replied too quickly! (Thank you by the way). I think this is really...

I agree that there could be far more detail, there are a lot of compromises in order to make the game easy to play. It may not have the...

Ok. Forget quantum for the moment. We get the independence. Do you see why the dependence in what you call "player driven" bothers...

I think you’ll be hard pressed to find anyone having an issue with those things, though it’s the internet so there’s always 1 somewhere...

A living world sandbox compared to a traditional railroad is not very GM driven. There’s more to GM driven than ‘independent of the...

Right. But that does mean I agree it is a mistake to describe the issue as just ‘quantum’. I think ‘quantum’ is mostly a misguided...

"Quantum" again! I thought we had settled this long time ago now. The issue isn't if it is "quantum" or not it is all about what kind of...

This is incredibly interesting! And I think this might be a good time to bring up my idea of "proto-games" as a way to describe a play...

your assertions that they are 'equally quantum' are untrue when for one roll the chances of the location of the cook has modifiers...

To me it's clear that some folk dislike making a skill roll to pick a lock the prompt that results in adding a cook to the fiction. For...

Things can get weird because a lot of Narrativist best practices aren't actually best practices and what gets ported between games is...

I don't know if my take is actually logical or even accepted interpretation. But it's satisfactory to me because it is an...