FrogReaver's latest activity

Again not what they want. You’re demonstrating this is an intractable problem.

The problem I'm having with your way of playing is that there are billions of NPCs out there and I cannot know more than a very small...

Upthread I listed features of implementations of fail forward that I have observed in various games. It is a version of fail forward...

That’s easy, they want to control 10 skeletons a turn entailing everything said 10 skeletons might do. Thus the intractable problem...

The problem with Gygax was that he was very schizophrenic in his writing, often writing passages and rules that were in complete...

Then you aren’t giving them what they want. Thus the intractable problem.

I am 100% certain. There was plenty of pushback on those other spell changes as well.

Thinking about this, I think the problem is, not every class can become a minionmancer (or maybe they could, see below). The sheer...

How do you think I found the example? An example that did sort of make sense to me (which I thought I mentioned long, long ago) was a...

First, to clarify-- heighten spell applies disadvantage to ONE saving throw, even if multiple entities are making saves. So it decidedly...

If you only ever use this concept in a PbtA game and never in a D&D game then I don't see how that it applies to D&D. The games have a...

What strawman have I used? The example I got was from a blog. I was not the one that came up with it, I never said it was a good...

Continuing that thought a bit... I don't know your table, but it is quite possible that, if most of you are experienced players, and...

I think that is a luxury only highly experienced GMs can usually give you. Newer GMs, or GMs new to a ruleset, generally have to...

No one knows. Or at least, it seems to me that there are several things being discussed at the same time. For a while it was the...