FrogReaver's latest activity

IMO Everyone grasps what you are doing. They just explain it differently. That is its different conclusions on the same set of facts.

@Enrahim I view imaginary things and player ideas of imaginary things as the same exact thing. Do you? I think that’s been a major...

Wait, you are quibbling over, the players idea of an imaginary thing vs the imaginary thing being the cause? To me the word imaginary...

Let me finish the part sentence you half quoted. Why did you feel like saying the same as me with so many more words?

I don’t think you answered @maxperson’s question here at all. Posting the skill doesn’t define what if any limitations it has from your...

If imaginary things don’t have real causal relations then how can one prompt a real player to author what the runes are?

How is the epistemic state in terms of the posibility regarding the posibility of the runes revealing something positive that isn't a...

Which can't possibly be the case if I-as-player am able to affect the fiction beyond what my character can know about, as seems to be...

this may be a result of confusion between people using both the uses of determine? between the process of finding the equivalent...

Oh, was that the logical connection to you were claimed to not make? That cannot be right? That seem completely illogical to me? After...

What I said and what you said aren't in conflict. You... 1) Allowed the use of that skill. 2) Stated that it was not only deception...

I guess you have boiled it a bit too much down if you have lost the important differences in the situations we are talking about. You...

Because he quoted the definition he uses and the rule was posted upthread. If the skill makes sense to apply to a situation, it can be...

But the method of establishment is what is under scrutiny here! In the cleric example the existence was handwaved. I thought the point...

I'd say it does, in that the player is being pulled from Actor stance into Author stance whether he wants to be or not. In Actor...