FrogReaver's latest activity

We know PHB sales much better than MM and DMG. Always has, always will. So I don’t know why the numbers on amazon are that way, but I...

the 2014 PHB has 54k votes, the 2024 PHB has 2k. Compare that to the 2024 DMG and MM at 30k votes each… wonder why the PHB has so few...

And my point was that to make such ratings you implicitly must be comparing to other beers.

‘Gnome Math’

I did. Looking at the poll results, however, shows x people as DMs and y people as players but doesn't tell us how many of those are...

"Both DM and Player" is missing as an option; as opposed to just one or just the other.

Then at most you could say I enjoy it or not. You couldn’t determine the difference in a 6 and a 10 without making other comparisons.

Relating it to all the other things you enjoy isn’t disagreement with me. It’s in perfect alignment with what I said.

$80? I really wish every hobby wasn't trying to price me out so effectively.

For what it’s worth I rated 2024e as a 6. Id have rated 2014e as a 7.

IMO it’s impossible to rate without some context around the rating. That might be other movies in general or other Superman movies or...

This seems like a pretty standard 4eism to me, and a general extension of the idea that monster and NPC stats exist entirely to govern...

Wait… no?

From the Rules Compendium: Checking the RC, I noticed the Minion rules say nothing about being defeated, destroyed or killed, just the...

What’s the rule for knocking a creature unconscious at zero hp?