FrozenNorth's latest activity

Why not? Is this based on your extensive reading of the rules of the game, and your experience of play?

How would this be resolved? If it takes (say) an hour or two of play time at the table, where the player is just moving through scenes...

There are sometimes limitations put on autonomy or carrots or sticks for particular actions, but these come as a consequence for...

Yes, in context of its potential impact on a larger view of play. Like when you consider all those kinds of things I mentioned in my...

I know, it's a pretty outrageous setting to posit that cold blooded murder might require someone to screw up their courage!

In its basic structure and methods - asymmetric participants with one managing scene-framing and the other saying what a particular...

Yes, I understand that. But, the way I see it, is that what you're arguing for allows for all those things I said. That all of that is...

Come on, Lanefan. You've been involved in these conversations for literally years. Have you really not realized by now that folks play...

No, that's not what anyone has said. What people have said is that the GM making the guards unfailingly loyal to the king... along with...

That conclusion would seem to me to require a willful misinterpretation of what was said.

Dude, I'm right here! This is also not what I've said.

A And I find the terms on which you want to limit the discussion to be as ideological and limited (and limiting) as you attribute...

Yeah, that's not something I generally want to see in play, either. At least, not for very long. A little color here and there is one...

“I can smell evil; it’s like a sixth sense. Actually, that would be one of the five…”

Yes, because there’s nothing self-centered about making me listen to your stakeless conversation with an NPC, lol.