GarrettKP's latest activity

This. The average person would see a group playing Daggerheart and say to themselves “those people are playing D&D.” It’s like how the...

Isn't this just replicating - or (if one thinks it's not a full replication) alluding to - the role of druids in AD&D Dark Sun as...

This thread has shown me a lot of people apparently have either forgotten or homebrewed what preserving and defiling meant.

Maybe so, but it's thematically more satisfying to say, "I'm trying to preserve, but the temptation to get extra power via defiling is...

If I had my druthers? Athasian variants for dwarves, elves, halflings, and goliaths; full species writeups for Thri-Kreen and Mul; Dray...

< sigh > 4E changed their backstory over 15 years ago. So the only person you "gotcha'd" there was yourself. They're obviously not...

I don't think they need any others. Muls need to be 4E-style, not "slave-breeding" style (ugh). Goliaths fit the half-giant role so...

So for the Dark Sun book, what species are we thinking they bring back? Thri-Kreen and Mul seem obvious, but are there any other that...

That's also been my experience. I'd even go further to say that most casual D&D observers, meaning people who've played at least one...

I call bologna on this whole line of argument! Yet again, you're trying to say that adding "male" to the list somehow removes "female*...

And that’s fine. I’m not saying it isn’t different, and new players can certainly feel the difference in my experience. But I played 8...

I’m not disputing that D&D isn’t at its peak right now. But I was at GenCon. I spent most of my time in the D&D area in Lucas Oil. I...

Who is, of course, unimpeachably unbiased.

I’ve never seen a post I’ve agreed with more. Very well said.

You realize some of the best art is also made not by the original artist, but by those who came later and reinterpreted it? What would...