Recent content by GuardianLurker

  1. GuardianLurker

    D&D General Eberron Hexcrawl Help

    OK, this is PF2e focused, but it'll translate easily into any d20 system. Some notes: Faranthal is my current home brew setting. Soul Coins are the campaign's metacurrency (augmenting PF2e's Hero Points). I'm using 6 mile hexes for the hexcrawl map. For my players, they generally spend about...
  2. GuardianLurker

    D&D General Eberron Hexcrawl Help

    NP. I'll post it in full in a bit. But the basic concept was: Take the normal movement per day in hexes (at your scale) in open terrain, call that X (for me it was 4 or 5). Add "activities" like scouting, mapping, be brave/bold/stupid (attract more encounters), find REALLY good long term camp...
  3. GuardianLurker

    D&D General Eberron Hexcrawl Help

    I'm running a (semi) hex-crawl right now with a similar setup - large scale known map, small scale exploration. 1. The best bet on how to integrate Lightning Rail, Airships, and other fast-but-not-instant travel is to limit the actual hexcrawl to wherever the PCs disembark, as has been...
  4. GuardianLurker

    Wish vs. Miracle

    The rules I have for PC wishes back in 2e/3e: 1. The wish must be a single sentence, and can have only one subject and one object. It can have any number of clauses affecting those terms, but a wish can only really do ONE thing. 2. Once you know the spell wish, and you tell me (the DM) you're...
  5. GuardianLurker

    D&D General Best way to classify modules

    Hmm. I think if I was going to do a revised system, I'd go: (Tier #)(Type Letter)\((Abbrev)\)[.Part #][Setting Letter)[- Index #] Where: Tier # == The rough level tier for the entry; 0 = 0-3; 1 = 4-8; 2 = 9 - 12; 3 = 13-16; 4 = 17-20; 5 = 20+/Epic Type Letter == A for Adventure Path/Series, C...
  6. GuardianLurker

    D&D 3.x Haste question

    So the thing with Haste and extra spells boils down to novas (i.e. blowing everything you have in a few encounters). To counter this: Quickened spells are expensive, if you're not using the metamagic staves. (Which, come to think of it, might be a 3.5 thing.) If you only allow quickened...
  7. GuardianLurker

    Paksworld RPG Based On Elizabeth Moon's Novels

    Not 1e; B/X. The progression from pure veteran fighter to called paladin lines up very neatly with the advanced classes of that system.
  8. GuardianLurker

    Psionics--the Poll!

    Yeah, 2e psionics was a lot better. It's my favorite, flavor-wise. Mechanically, it was a bit wonky. Most of the wonkiness could be avoided just be every avoid just by everyone being reasonable in their power use. But even so, there were a couple of powers that were ... imbalanced. And...
  9. GuardianLurker

    Psionics--the Poll!

    No, in fairness, 1e psionics was broken mechanically. In large part because psionics was wildly different than magic, it was a "tacked on" subsystem, and characters didn't have anything approaching default defenses against psionics according to the subsystem. And the psionic monsters (like the...
  10. GuardianLurker

    Psionics--the Poll!

    I should caveat that while I want psionics, I don't want just a reflavoring. The closer the psionics system captures the flavor of the Deryni novels the better I like it, flavor-wise. (Or Norton's Witchworld's.) But mechanically, it has to fit into the same power structure as the existing...
  11. GuardianLurker

    D&D 5E (2014) Why Do Higher Levels Get Less Play?

    It's long been established that the length of the average campaign is approximately 6 months. Or, if meeting every week, 24 sessions. At a 4 session/level pace (which is what's recommended), that's 6 levels. That's simply just not enough time to climb up to the higher levels. Now, I don't...
  12. GuardianLurker

    How likely are you to use D&D for your next game?

    I answered "Not Sure." But that's an incomplete answer. It's "Not Sure" because 1) We're not currently using 5e (PF2e Remaster for the current campaign); 2) The current campaign is FAR from over (probably another 2+ years at their current pace). 3) I'm the Forever GM, and I'm not sure the next...
  13. GuardianLurker

    D&D General Alignments in a sentence/phrase/whatever

    This is getting harder, as many of the obvious stances have already been used. LG: The Law Protects. LN: Obey the Law. LE: The law serves my needs. NG: There is Good, and there is Evil. It's not hard to tell them apart. N: Not my circus, not my monkey, not my problem. NE: My needs matter, yours...
  14. GuardianLurker

    TSR Level Titles

    The only ones I ever retained were the Magic-User/Wizard ones, since they can/do correspond to Spell Level increases. Looking at these, I homebrewed the titles a lot more than I remembered. I use Wizard 1st-Level Spells: Apprentice 2nd-Level Spells: Journeyman 3rd-Level Spells: Magician...
  15. GuardianLurker

    D&D General D&D memes thread discussion…

    Re: D&D General - The D&D Memes Thread You can charge extra if you teach it to dance. As long as it isn't the chicken dance.
Top