hawkeyefan's latest activity

I don’t think you can speak to quality without comparison. When I compare 5e to other games, I don’t know if there’s any component of...

It does not follow. The Model T was hugely successful. Documented as not a quality product by the standards of that day. The Yugo...

Not necessarily. It could simply be that they are using different criteria. Granted, that choice of criteria may be subjective, but...

The primary issue with this thread is Oofta hasn’t actually defined “quality”. Without specifics it is impossible to discuss. But I...

Ahh irony. By your own standard, you admit that your argument is low quality.

Some great posts in this thread. I’ve been busy this week so I’ve not had a lot of time to post. I finally managed to watch the video...

Even if you only end up using a few of Spire's ideas for a totally different campaign/system, it's absolutely worth picking up.

This seems like an occupational hazard with high concept rpgs and settings - the higher the concept, the harder it is to bring to life...

What games beside D&D 5e would you classify as quality games? I don’t think it’s about the popularity of your opinion so much as about...

But can you and the people you play with articulate why 5e is a good quality product without engaging in a circular argument that...

I'm going to say this again, because I think it got buried before. "Fun" is not a measure of quality. How much you enjoy a thing is...

As reasonable adults, people should absolutely be able to say that they personally like a product whilst at the same time recognizing it...

When you phrase it like that, it definitely has echoes of anti-intellectualism.

This whole line of argument just grinds my gears. The idea that a 17 year old kid microwaving a hamburger tossing together from company...

I don't doubt that it was deliberate. Being deliberate doesn't make it good. And, this is just Mearls punting on the issue. His...