hawkeyefan's latest activity

I gotta say, AW is pretty strong about wanting things to stay in character, and DW is also rather explicit here. But that being said...

It’s part of it, yes. But I also find that you just don’t need to worry all that much about separating what the players know from what...

It’s very clearly stated that the guard heard the singing and came to see what was going on,

I don’t know. “Unconnected” seems pretty clear. And I would say all the consequences are clearly connected to the actions. Well, maybe...

"Optimizing the fiction" to shape the outcome range is definitely part of what I see as fiction-first gameplay, for the games that bring...

So what did your post have to do with what I said? I was asked how I handle a situation in this post from @Lanefan: The context of...

I'm simply not old enough to know about any of the early days of the hobby, but I definitely see this coming up the most as a complaint...

No… again, I don’t care if you like it or not. But the way in which you describe it… the reasons you give for not liking it, contain...

I think it is less a focus of play, for sure. Like, I cannot ever see play of a narrativist game devolving into a series of standard...

It’s not moving the goalposts. It’s a disagreement with the context someone extracted from the statement. If someone says “it’s...

Here's a post I made over 10 years ago, that quotes a bit about how some resolution methods facilitate certain sorts of approaches to...

So for some initial clarity: meaningfulness is something that the participants in a game experience. Then, when we talk about managing...

So?

That was how I felt when I saw it; the most radical thing seemed the handling of spells and the attack rolls against Reflex, Fortitude...

I don't disagree with your assesment of many of the posts in this thread. My response was intended to be limited to your specific...