hawkeyefan's latest activity

Like I said, this line of conversation has devolved into certain posters doing the online equivalent of sticking their fingers in their...

No it doesn't. It also means no one inside is able to get out through the door. I feel like I've taken crazy pills! Yes, and I'm...

I don't think there's one answer for your question here. I am only passingly familiar with Starforged, having read Ironsworn. I've not...

The example with the burning house was in no way about the cause of the fire. Again... let's set aside the game for now and just think...

I said "PbTA" earlier, but I was really thinking about my experience playing Starforged / Ironsworn. So everything I've said before and...

I think this can be something that does happen with D&D and more traditionally designed games. Everything is focused on the task, and...

I think this will depend on what the game is. But the PbtA games I'm familiar with - mostly AW and DW - say when a player-side move is...

I never claimed it started the fire. I don't even know how you would have drawn that conclusion. It's amazing to me how you guys are...

Yeah, the real problem here is the richness of the world being described being vastly, almost unimaginably, less than reality. In...

You just can't answer the question directly, huh? Forget gameplay for a moment. If in real life, if someone was trying to open the...

Are you going to tell us what rules you use to establish valid action declaration in the intent + task RPGs that you play? Or in any of...

Are you actually reading the examples?

I think @hawkeyefan's point is simpler than you are making it out to be. It is not a point about game play; it is a simple point about...

I've been lurking around this thread for a while, but this discussion has been very eye-opening, and it's really helping me understand...

Not necessarily. Thethings can all be minor or all be major. The point is that they are sensible consequences of the situation. It...