hawkeyefan's latest activity

I think this shows a similar idiosyncrasy to mine with roll-under. There's acknowledgement that it's not born of logic, but...

Sure, I'm not disagreeing with that. But with the wider implication that this is all that's always needed, and is always provided. No...

This is fail forward. You continue to ignore clarifications on what fail forward means and instead continue to work with your flawed...

Even at night--depending on the exact hour--a cook could still be around, preparing things for the next day, closing up, possibly using...

Yes, I find that equally ridiculous. The characters in most of my narrativist games tend to be at least as substantive as any in my trad...

What's the difference between those things? Like seriously. In practice, what's the difference? Because as far as I can tell, "you put...

I may or may not. I mean, as has been discussed, failure on a climb check could mean a number of things. So, if a PC falls, they may...

Considering that the GM is the one who makes up all the factors that may be considered when coming up with the timing, they may as well...

Yes, it is a change. It's not a direct violation of the integrity of the roll, though. This is a perfectly valid way to handle the...

In mainstream D&D, if you hope for your PC to climb the cliff, and you then succeed at your roll, your hope comes true: the fiction now...

Agreed. Right! The players' actions don't matter, because all they do is change or add to the shared fiction. To truly matter, they must...

I think it's funny how multiple posters who have attacked the cook and have repeatedly insisted they aren't interested in hearing how a...

Huh? There was a whole sub-culture of complaint about 4e D&D - spearheaded by The Alexandrian - based on the fact that many 4e mechanics...

What RPG, or whose RPGing, are you trying to describe here? I mean, the overall tenor of your posts suggests you think that you are...

This is not true. The player described an action performed by their character: deciphering the runes, hoping that they would show a way...