hawkeyefan's latest activity

They’re both examples of GM authority going further than the players would want. In the case of railroading, it’s possible some players...

Characters don't think. Players think about what their characters would think.

Yes you are. Incorrect.

I think @pemerton uses the word to describe a game that involves the players playing through the GM’s prepared story. Where the GM...

Pemerton is unable to answer this query due to a thread ban.

As far as I can tell, no one did. You seemed to misread the idea that a player would know their place in the game (like, their role in...

He did. I mean… the name of the ability was enough for many of us. None of us decided to google the definition of “cunning” and then...

And yet… no one posting in this thread who is familiar with these kinds of games shares your concern. Why do you think that is? Are we...

Games are not just collections of mechanics. They also have objectives, agendas and social rewards they are built upon. If you export...

What you call a "mental map" some of us just call memory. But suppose that he had never travelled in Moria, but had read a description...

But is your assertion that this action declaration can't be resolved in MHRP. Why not? What are the character's Milestones? What is the...

That sort of "but actually" nonsense is the province of children and lawyers. No one here has to be Jeremy Crawford defending rules...

Good thing there isn't, then. Glad I could help you out, since you seemed extremely confused. Again, I have no idea what you're...

This is getting increasingly bizarre. I told you what the Cunning specialty covers: I don't remember anyone at my trouble finding this...

And again, the fact that the mechanical resolution method takes player intent and character modifiers into account INSTEAD OF being a...