• The VOIDRUNNER'S CODEX is coming! Explore new worlds, fight oppressive empires, fend off fearsome aliens, and wield deadly psionics with this comprehensive boxed set expansion for 5E and A5E!

Recent content by hudarklord

  1. H

    Wizards in leather

    Re: those who asked why armor should cause arcane casting failure, in DragonQuest used to say (a la the fairie weakness) that wrought iron interfered with magic. So mages could wear plain leather, but more heavily metalic armors interfered with casting. When I first built my 4E Wizard I was...
  2. H

    CustServ on "What is 'an attack'?"

    How about Cleave (Fighter 1)? When you hit, you also do damage to an opponent who you didn't make an attack roll against. Wow! By my reading, there's an Attack Power which has a to hit roll, but which does 3 damage to a different adjacent opponent, and that 3 damage is not an attack. What...
  3. H

    PHB p. 281 Cover Rules Question

    Thanks very much. Good find. Didn't know that rule existed. Thanks again. Cheers, Lee
  4. H

    PHB p. 281 Cover Rules Question

    On p. 281 there's a diagram showing who has cover and who doesn't in the graphic. Assuming that the bugbears are allies and that all bugbears are enemies of the attacker, isn't the bugbear in the lower left corner behind cover (his ally). The bugbear closest to the interior black wall seems...
  5. H

    Elements of Magic: Revised -- here at last!

    Discounts for previous owners Are there any discounts for purchasers of previous versions?
  6. H

    No ECL in the SRD. Why are d20 publishers able to use it?

    Are you saying that you think rules don't embody a "concept". That's an acceptable type of PI. It's not limited to characters and creatures. I'd say that rules are by definition concepts. The statement of rules is "language". The display of rules is "formatting". Where a concept is written...
  7. H

    No ECL in the SRD. Why are d20 publishers able to use it?

    Why is this hard at all? Product Identity is not merely limited to trademarks. Since you can protect formatting (used to display the rules), language (used to describe the rules), themes (which represent those intangible "look & feel" things you may trying to convey -- in your game world...
  8. H

    No ECL in the SRD. Why are d20 publishers able to use it?

    Actually, unless the descriptive part is merely commentary (say, on how good Southern food tastes to the author in the summertime), then even the descriptive parts of the task itself may not be copyrightable. HOWEVER, one thing that may be copyrightable is the selection of facts. If you went...
  9. H

    No ECL in the SRD. Why are d20 publishers able to use it?

    First, WotC didn't PI the term "ECL", they just didn't release it as OGC. That is VERY VERY different. If they PI it, then unless you can show that you got the term from somewhere else, then you can't use the term in any work which Section 15s the work containing the definition of PI. If WotC...
  10. H

    No ECL in the SRD. Why are d20 publishers able to use it?

    Actually, Green Ronin and a couple of other publishers have specifically chosen not to agree with #1 above. They have PI'd mechanics. I think the license can be read as to allow for this. Consider this. A person is allergic to strawberries, but likes many other fruits. They might say, "my...
  11. H

    Product Identity & Formatting

    As I've said before, since people have mentioned that you police matters like this and it was my primary concern, then my concerns are now much more limited. Thanks for the reply. Cheers, Lee Valentine PS Kudos on your increasing sales trends -- I saw a sales chart a little while ago and it...
  12. H

    Product Identity & Formatting

    That's what I've been trying to say. If you release 100% OGC, what stops someone from pulling the file into a distiller, ripping out your artwork and borders and stuff? Nothing. So your senario of copying my PDF and sell it for $3 less is still viable, it just takes a few more minutes of work...
  13. H

    Product Identity & Formatting

    A great answer. Thanks. Lee
  14. H

    PDFs with no art

    Re: Me Too Alan -- you are a wonderful person with wonderful advice. Thanks. The fontography and layout info was very interesting and useful. Cheers, Lee
  15. H

    Product Identity & Formatting

    That's very useful information. Thanks. I'm not so concerned about things being pirated by people dedicated to the mission. I'm really only interested in two things: a) creating a really minimal hurdle which makes fairly honest people realize that there's something on the page they...
Top