Hussar's latest activity

I think Micah has never been on Reddit :P. I remember a group of new players I took on had only done a little one shot before, the GM...

Have you not seen the NUMEROUS times people refer to an "objective" world, to being forced by the setting to make a decision, to having...

And yet you keep saying you want the setting "independent". That you want a "physics" engine or the like. That you want an "objective"...

No. That's where you are wrong. Good enough isn't the objective. A system that is robust enough to generate results independently of...

Again, you're conflating different things. You cannot have logical outputs from completely illogical inputs. Sure, you plonk down 46...

You keep using this word logic and I don't think it means what you think it means. There is no such thing as logic when you CREATE the...

((Note, I left off the accountable to players bit since that's not relevant to my point)) He very much has repeatedly claimed that he...

Well, if that's true, then @robertsconley's whole methodolgy falls apart doesn't it? Since his entire line or reasoning is that the DM...

How is you deciding what goes on that chart not deciding what is plausible? Since anything that is on that chart isn't just...

Doesn't matter. 1e D&D. Rules are silent.

Not at all. I think that there is virtually zero difference between what @robertsconley does and virtually any other good DM does...

So, most of your decisions are basically whatever you feel is good at the time. Which, somehow, means that you are basing your...

But, that's exactly what the whole "internal logic" line of argument is claiming. That the decisions are not coming from the DM, but...

A miscommunication has nothing to do with what we are talking about though. We're talking about the resolution of events somehow being...

Ok. So, the DM decides that the King will not talk to your PC's for reasons. You disagree with the reasons because you think they are...