I'm A Banana's latest activity

How big does the difference need to be? Like, Paladins and Rangers and Barbarians are just Fighters if you squint. Druids are just...

That's weird, I don't have any modern tech that let's me read minds. But modern tech is WAY better at mass transit and communication. I...

Personally, I think a lot of D&D's success can be attributed to doing a lot of different kinds of games well enough that it's fine. That...

And here I am, thinking that campaign logistics are the most directly gamified aspect of the RPG and high adventure the most directly...

Totally off topic: I want to save this line forever. The day someone called millennials old and gave them the boomer treatment. 😆 Btw...

The aesthetic did change, and that's what I was talking about. The OP might be mistaken about the historical accuracy of D&D, but that...

I've played a Ravnica game that was pretty successful. The party consisted of 3 members of Selesnya (a paladin, a wizard, and a...

I am quick to bust out the Abe Simpson quote. Change frequently surprises people, even though it's inevitable. Every time one of my...

This is a more cogent argument than that it’s no longer medieval fantasy because there are handlebar mustaches. That said, it’s not like...

One of the interesting things about how D&D grew was that it grew out of wargames, where historical accuracy matters quite a bit more...

Alignment as a restrictive rule that one must obey (as originally conceived) is borked. It was the GM's job to police your behavior...

Edit to add: Historical accuracy has never been a significant part of fantasy, nor should it be. Something not being medieval-accurate...

I can name you two - Prince of Nothing and A Land Fit For Heroes. They're both awful (and both weirdly obsessed with sexual assault far...

I really really like Radiant Citadel.

Now this post actually has a point and I think there is something interesting worth discussing here. It’s something I have been thinking...