Imaro's latest activity

I don't think experiences really signify things you are unquestionably good at(...at least no moreso than a 5e Fighter having more skill...

I think the system intentionally avoids giving a mechanical incentive to choose permanent death. There are some minor influences, like...

To me the weird or awkward one is "Risk It All"... and maybe that's because I don't think my players will ever use it. I mean from a...

Yes I'm not saying anyone is wrong, and I'm not the one insinuating if you read the entire book you can only come to one...

I think Daggerheart is a really good game and I am currently running a campaign for it. But fans of DH claiming they don't get why...

For the final time that doesn't answer my question.

It gives all this advice and then it's tip for a player having trouble picking an experience in a standard battle campaign is to select...

How does that incentivize you to choose permanent death at a narratively appropriate time? That's an incentive to choose the move...

So no mechanical incentivization... That was my point. And it's not about the rules deciding, it's about the rules rewarding the play...

Again the advice you are citing is standard in many traditional rpg's including D&D. You don't roll for trivial things or challenges...

How does this incentivize it to happen at a narratively appropriate moment? I definitely can see it being used at a narratively...

Yes but this is just GM fiat... and most games, even 5e do this when it comes to things the PC would resonably know/be able to...

I get this but that's kind of my point the mechanics don't incentivize picking the death option that would create the most satisfying...

Advice is good... but without mechanical incentive to back it up it's not really going to be effective. And yet if you watch AoU what...

sure we can roll for stats, just so long as everyone has to use the same set of resulting stats.