Imaro's latest activity

Look you seem intent on sticking with your incorrect assumptions about the book and seem to truly believe it's bad. You're asking for a...

That, and, you know, it is said to be ethnically diverse, to have a cooperative and egalitarian society, a public, transparent...

I want to believe thats the main problem but you bring faerie or the Fey into it and suddenly colorful can be plenty dark & dangerous...

not well regarded by who? You gave a single video from an OSR channel. I mean repeating something with no evidence doesn't make it any...

What in the text gave the vibe of it being an utopia? I didn't get that at all form it and many of the adventures in the book have low...

12 archmages with all the ego, personal goals, desires etc. that being powerful mages entail.... And they protect the Citadel from...

It being a utopia is not actually supported at all by the text.

Is Sigil "safe" because it has The Lady of Pain... she's more powerful than 12 archmages. You're dismissing the internal...

People call the radiant citadel a utopia, but I don’t think that’s really supported by the text…? Its society is fairly egalitarian, but...

Well this thread has inspired me to start brainstorming a campaign where The Radiant Citadel, Sigil and Ravnica are all different...

If anyone is actually interested in a pretty even handed take on Journeys Through the Radiant Citadel...its not too long but there are...

So the writer in question won an award as an emerging designer, was called a bad writer by people who didn't read her works. The writer...

That videos from an OSR focused channel... color me not surprised...

Silly? The Citadel didn't strike me as particularly silly, no more (and probably less so) than Forgotten Realms, Greyhawk or Mystara. I...

Could you elaborate on why exactly you think its not very good?