James Gasik's latest activity

Exactly! I hate 3/.5 and I still regard the 3.5 ranger as the best iteration thus far, except maybe the 5e Revised Ranger from UA. I...

I enjoyed reading this thread and discovering all of the differing ideas about what constitutes a Ranger. I also found it very...

And again, if you're an experienced DM, you can probably make these intent calls. But not every DM is going to be able to read between...

Yeah, I know, I remember a lot of people in the past griping that "WotC took away the DM's authority" and "players are too entitled"...

Forcing "rulings over rules" is really a bad idea. I mean, it's true that every group is going to play the game that's best for them...

Yeah. As I mentioned upthread, a lot of this vagueness is in my opinion deliberate to force rulings over rules.

These are good posts. the D&D rules simply aren't drafted with sufficient precision to support the intricacate readings that some...

Well you've got to post #1364, of course!

I mean, I know it's a typo, but the idea we'll still be edition warring 889 years from now fills me with hope and dread simultaneously.

Seriously! There's a lot I really like about Revised Ranger, and wish got folded back into later attempts! Particularly the combat...

Does anyone remember the Revised Ranger from UA? They released it online, allowed people to play it in one season of Adventure League...

Made worse by the fact that nothing is supernatural about the Warlord. Healing in D&D does not require magic or supernatural abilities...

I get what you're saying. But you have to admit it's weird for the book to make a list of possible actions, slap Ready on there, and...

It didn't exist back then. WOTC wanted to copy the popular 4E Hunter's Quarry for 5e. However they didn't think the old school DMs they...

Because the original target audience for 5V were guarding arts would not allow an ability like hunters Mark 2 not be a magical effect...