James Gasik's latest activity

Interestingly, this is a feature of the AD&D version of the Broom:

The only time I think I've ever seen a Broom of Flying in play was back when I played in AL. The party Rogue had gotten one somehow (I...

x I mean, if your character has a Str of 10, being allowed to use your 19 Charisma for attack and damage rolls with a weapon sure feels...

I’m trying to think of the opposite. If the intent was for it not to function How could it be worded to make that clear? I don’t see...

The bolded is where we disagree, I think. And if a player wants to have their character spend the time, money, and creativity to make...

This wording would remove any bonuses to hit with the weapon, so you'd need to add in a line about that.

Seems clean enough to me, but an alternative way would probably be something like. "Make a spell attack roll within the weapons range...

In 5e2014, explicitly calling the strike from True Strike a Spell Attack would be the cleanest solution. But posts from others have...

Hey, that was the beauty of 4E. Every fight your green and red powers were available. And you never got more than 4 black dailies.

Out of curiosity, if the intent was for True Strike to function with this feature, what wording would the feature require to make it...

The PCs action for the round is being use to do what? Is it swing a sword or cast a spell? It seems to me that it is used to cast a...

I'm starting to think True Strike is the problem here. This feels like Agonizing Blast + True Strike all over again.

It's was D&D. It just was with 10 fixes when the community was ready for 5 in 2008. In 2025 today, the community wanted all 10 of 4e...

Do remember that calling 4e "some other game" is, for a lot of us fans, straight-up fighting words. "Your game is awesome but it doesn't...