kayakingpoodle's latest activity

my problem is that is it incoherent. On one hand, they grouped certain "types" together - now soldier, veteran and champion are...

I originally used "unconnected" because it was for examples of a guard showing up due to a failed song when they would not have appeared...

And yet not the cause. It's just connected in a distant way. Then everything in the world is caused by everything in the world. We...

If you're a new DM, do you even know the names of creatures? Not having all the devils, demons, and dragons together means you can't...

Lots. The criteria are too varied to list. I'd have to be in a game when a specific set of circumstances came up before I could figure...

It is the first part of a chain of events that led to you reading this thread.

If I had not gotten out of bed this morning I would not be reading this thread. Did my getting out of bed cause me to read this?

I didn't say it is a good idea. Under what circumstances would you as GM add something to the fiction? It's not in your prep or on the...

Sure. He can also add Godzilla. The ability to add stuff doesn't inherently make it a good idea. And guess what I didn't cause? That...

I believe the 2024 books are intended to be the new baseline for the future, with the intent to bring new players into the fold now that...

They will have a difficult problem changing anything in a physical book I own that is on my bookshelf. As for errata for later...

To me, it just seems like an oversight more than anything.

I think the lack of page numbers in the index\reference portions of the book is a large part of the "it feels like the physical book was...

Not including the page numbers is really bad design.

I actually prefer the current organization. I simply can't be bothered to remember whether an Incubus is a Devil or Demon. Or that...